Ethereum

David Vance

April

Security

Consensys, a prominent Ethereum development company, has fired the latest salvo in the ongoing battle between the crypto industry and the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The company <a href="https://consensys.io/crypto-regulations/defend-ethereum" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">filed a lawsuit</a> on April 25th, accusing the SEC of an “unlawful seizure of authority” over Ethereum, the world’s second-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization. 
The lawsuit centers around the SEC’s recent actions towards Consensys, particularly its popular MetaMask wallet product. MetaMask allows users to store, manage, and trade cryptocurrencies, including <a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/ethereum" target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow">Ethereum (ETH).</a> However, the SEC appears to be taking aim at specific features within MetaMask, like its staking and swap functionalities. 
<h2 data-sourcepos="7:1-7:52" id="strong-consensys-pushes-back-on-security-classification-strong">Consensys Pushes Back On Security Classification</h2> 
The company is seeking a definitive court ruling that declares ETH is not a security. This classification is crucial, as securities regulations can significantly impact how cryptocurrencies are traded and offered. <a href="https://fortune.com/crypto/2024/04/25/sec-sued-over-ethereum-crypto-firm-asks-court-to-state-token-is-not-a-security/" target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow">Consensys</a> argues that Ethereum, with its decentralized network and lack of a central issuer, doesn’t meet the traditional definition of a security. 
The case also explores MetaMask’s functionality. According to the firm, the wallet is just an interface and not a broker. By asserting that MetaMask never retains user assets nor handles transaction execution directly, they effectively distance themselves from any possible infraction of securities regulations. 
According to Joe Lubin, co-founder of Ethereum and founder/CEO of Consensys: 
<blockquote>
 We don’t take this step lightly, but we feel compelled to act. Ethereum is for everyone. 
</blockquote> 
<h2 data-sourcepos="13:1-13:53" id="strong-consensys-cites-inconsistent-regulatory-landscape-strong">Consensys Cites Inconsistent Regulatory Landscape</h2> 
Further complicating the situation is the SEC’s seemingly contradictory stance on Ethereum. The lawsuit references a 2018 speech by former SEC director Bill Hinman, where he classified Ethereum as a commodity, not a security. 
Additionally, the firm argues that the SEC’s sister agency, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), already oversees derivative products tied to Ethereum. This perceived overlap in regulatory jurisdiction strengthens Consensys’ argument against the SEC’s recent actions. 
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter size-full" src="https://www.tradingview.com/x/Gp99a6rM/" width="2475" height="1163"> Leaning On Legal Precedents 
The lawsuit also invokes the “major questions doctrine,” a legal principle that limits the power of federal agencies when their actions have broad economic or political implications. Consensys argues that the SEC’s attempt to regulate Ethereum falls under this doctrine and requires explicit Congressional authorization. However, the effectiveness of this argument remains uncertain, as two judges have already rejected similar claims from other crypto companies. Wider Implications For Crypto Industry 
The Consensys lawsuit is a significant development with potential ramifications for the entire crypto industry. A court ruling in favor of Consensys could establish a clearer regulatory framework for Ethereum and similar cryptocurrencies. Conversely, a victory for the SEC could empower the agency to exert greater control over the crypto space, potentially leading to stricter regulations and increased scrutiny for companies like Consensys. 
Featured image from Zachary Fruhling, chart from TradingView

David Vs. Goliath? Crypto Firm Consensys Sues SEC Over Ethereum Regulation

Table of Contents

Bitcoinist

Other articles published on Apr 26, 2024

Custodia Bank Files Appeal After Court Ruling on Federal Reserve Account Access

Crypto Security Experts Offer Tips for Newcomers Amid Rising Phishing Threats

Justin Sun Executes Major BNB Transfer

Bitcoin ETFs Under Stress, Options Data Project Tough Recovery

Top Altcoin Picks for 2024–2025 Crypto Bull Run

Breakout Alert: PEPE, Polkadot, and BlastUP Gear Up for a Bull Run

Join our free newsletter for daily crypto updates!