CoinMarketCap: Read what our contributors have to say. This content is provided by the community. DYOR!
UK court rules Tether is property in first English law post-trial crypto ruling
Table of Contents
Market Musing-g

UK court rules Tether is property in first English law post-trial crypto ruling

Cointelegraph
By Cointelegraph
Created 7 months ago, last updated 7 months ago
3 mins read
UK court rules Tether is property in first English law post-trial crypto ruling

The United Kingdom High Court has ruled that stablecoin Tether is property — the first-ever ruling under English law on the treatment and status of cryptocurrency after a full trial.

The legal status of Tether (USDT) was a preliminary issue in a case brought by a fraud victim whose stolen crypto — including Tether — was offloaded through various crypto exchanges after being put through crypto mixers.
“USDT attract property rights under English law,” High Court of Justice Deputy Judge Richard Farnhill said in the Sept. 12 ruling.

The judge added that USDT was “rather a distinct form of property not premised on an underlying legal right” and can be the “subject of tracing and can constitute trust property in the same way as other property.”

He noted a “strong line of authority” that cryptocurrencies are property from a 2019 judgment in the same court that wasn’t made at trial. It was also consistent with the England and Wales Law Commission’s position in a 2023 digital assets report marking them as property.

The decision comes one day after a UK government bill would clarify that non-fungible tokens (NFTs), cryptocurrency and carbon credits are “things” and “personal property” under property laws.

Thai crypto exchange ducks suit

The victim and suit plaintiff Fabrizio D’Aloia failed to show that Thai exchange BitKub was “enriched” by receiving 400,000 USDT — of which 46,291 USDT was supposedly traced from D’Aloia’s fraudsters — the judge ruled.
Farnhill acknowledged the fraud but wasn’t convinced that a BitKub wallet received D’Aloia’s USDT because of the use of crypto mixers.

Quillon Law partner Nicola McKinney, who represented Bitkub, explained to Cointelegraph that the judge concluded USDT could, in principle, be identified in mixed pools, but D’Aloia “could not evidence on the balance of probabilities that any of his USDT could be traced to the relevant Bitkub wallet.”

Farnhill said there was no “defective transaction” between D’Aloia and Bitkub to “undo.”

“The legal link connecting Mr D’Aloia with Bitkub is simply missing from his claim. For this reason, too, he cannot succeed in his breach of trust claim.”

Matt Green, the blockchain and digital assets head at law firm Lawrence Stephens, told Cointelegraph the case is a lesson for analytic report providers to ensure evidence is clearly articulated by courts.

“It is vital that legal teams understand the fact patterns carefully in order to advance proprietary claims and ensure mixing issues are dealt with accordingly,” he said.

The court heard that D’Aloia transferred a total of 2.5 million British pounds ($3.3 million) to the fraudsters across several transactions.

D’Aloia also named Binance, Polo Digital Assets, Gate Technology Corp, Aux Cayes Fintech and the scammers, who are named as “persons unknown.”

An application for summary judgment against the parties is to be determined, and consequential orders will be heard at a later date.

0 likes
|

Other articles published on Sep 13, 2024

Market Musing-g

Investors Eye Altcoin Price Surge

Bitcoin’s rise to nearly $60,000 is drawing attention as it signals a potentially vigorous weekend for altcoins. A surge in trading volumes is expected to boost enthusiasm, possibly leading to quic...
By BH NEWS
7 months ago
2 mins read
Market Musing-g

Wormhole Brings World ID to Solana

This is a significant move because it opens up new opportunities for developers on Solana, allowing them to use World ID’s unique verification system. World ID is a special tool that helps prove wh...
By Altcoin Buzz
7 months ago
3 mins read
Market Musing-g

Using Crypto for CSGO Gambling: A Look at Crypto and Gaming

As a gamer and crypto enthusiast, I’ve been exploring different ways to combine my interests. Looking at WalletInvestor.com for cryptocurrency insights and discovered how it relates to CSGO gamblin...
By WalletInvestor
7 months ago
3 mins read
Blog

AVAX, DOT Show Positive Signs as Patterns Point to Reversals

Polkadot (DOT) and Avalanche (AVAX) are approaching breakouts from falling wedge patterns, signaling potential bullish reversals as momentum slows.
By CryptoTale
7 months ago
2 mins read
Market Musing-g

Family kicks as Binance Executive, Tigran Gambaryan spends 200 days in Nigerian detention

The family of detained Binance executive, Tigran Gambaryan have expressed concerns about his state, as today marks 200… The post Family kicks as Binance Executive, Tigran Gambaryan spends 200 days ...
By Technext.ng
7 months ago
5 mins read
Market Musing-g

Samsung Next Invests in Startale Labs, Partner in Sony’s Soneium Blockchain Development

Startale Labs, which is closely aligned with Astar Network, recently formed a joint venture with Sony to develop the Soneium Layer 2 blockchain.
By BSCN
7 months ago
3 mins read

Join the thousands already learning crypto!

Join our free newsletter for daily crypto updates!